Get Adobe Flash player

NYTimes on Open Data

Eric Jaye's picture
Submitted by Eric Jaye on Sat, 03/12/2011 - 8:38pm

NYT weighs in on benefits of public access to government data. Uses SF as example of innovation.

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/13/business/13view.html?ref=technology

 

 

This Data Isn’t Dull. It Improves Lives.

By RICHARD H. THALER

GOVERNMENTS have learned a cheap new way to improve people’s lives. Here is the basic recipe:

Take data that you and I have already paid a government agency to collect, and post it online in a way that computer programmers can easily use. Then wait a few months. Voilà! The private sector gets busy, creating Web sites and smartphone apps that reformat the information in ways that are helpful to consumers, workers and companies.

Not surprisingly, San Francisco, with its proximity to Silicon Valley, has been a pioneer in these efforts. For some years, Bay Area transit systems had been tracking the locations of their trains and buses via onboard GPS. Then someone got the bright idea to post that information in real time. Thus the delightful app Routesy was born. Install it on a smartphone and the app can tell you that your bus is stuck in traffic and will be 10 minutes late — or it can help you realize that you are standing on the wrong street, dummy. It gives consumers a great new way to find out when and where the bus is coming, and all at minimal government expense.

Another example involves weather data produced by the National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration. The forecasts you find on the Weather Channel, or on the evening news or online, use the agency’s information. Again, the government produces and releases raw data, and the private sector transforms it into something useful for the public.

Several other departments in the Obama administration are looking to expand the use of such techniques. On data.gov, you will find huge amounts of downloadable data that had heretofore been inaccessible. As a sign of the importance that President Obama has attached to this approach, he put it on the government’s agenda on Jan. 21, 2009, his second day in office. (Disclosure: My book, “Nudge,” published in 2008, advocated this broad idea; Cass R. Sunstein, co-author of the book, is now administrator of the White House Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs.)

Now the administration is pushing to use this concept as a tool for regulation, and as a method of avoiding more heavy-handed rule making. The idea is that making things more transparent can immediately turn consumers into better shoppers and make markets work better. One might think that such an initiative would receive nearly universal support — after all, who could be against openness and transparency? But it turns out that some people are.

Two cases are under discussion right now.

First, the Department of Transportation is considering a new rule requiring airlines to make all of their prices public and immediately available online. The postings would include both ticket prices and the fees for “extras” like baggage, movies, food and beverages. The data would then be accessible to travel Web sites, and thus to all shoppers.

The airlines would retain the right to decide how and where to sell their products and services. But many of them are insisting that they should be able to decide where and how to display these extra fees. The issue is likely to grow in importance as airlines expand their lists of possible extras, from seats with more legroom to business-class meals served in coach.

Electronic disclosure of all fees can make it much easier for consumers to figure out what a trip really costs, and thus make markets more efficient, without requiring new rules and regulations. (As someone who once bought two tickets on a discount airline from London to Dublin for the advertised price of £1 each, then ended up paying hundreds of dollars for the privilege of bringing along two heavy suitcases, I acknowledge having a sore spot on this issue.)

Another initiative has been proposed by the Consumer Product Safety Commission. In 2008, Congress overwhelmingly passed and President George W. Bush signed legislation mandating an online database of reported safety issues in products, at saferproducts.gov. The Web site ran for a few months in a “soft launch” and went into full operation on Friday.

But a majority in the House of Representatives passed an amendment last month that might have stopped this initiative in its tracks. The amendment, sponsored by Representative Mike Pompeo, a Kansas Republican, would have prohibited the agency from spending any further money to start the site. One goal, of course, was to cut the budget, although proponents of the amendment also argue that the Web site might include information that is erroneous and damaging to the businesses that sell children’s products.

Yet several provisions in the final rules protect manufacturers from false or malicious statements. Consumers have to include identifying information and sign an affidavit testifying to the truth of their complaints. Furthermore, manufacturers will be able to see complaints before they are posted, and can then correct mistakes or add comments.

ALTHOUGH this amendment was passed in the name of deficit reduction, the requested money for the site is a puny $3 million a year. If we want to reduce the cost of government regulation, this is exactly the kind of effort we should be applauding and expanding.

Compared with the tiny costs, the benefits of this program could be enormous. Thirteen years ago, two of my dear friends experienced the nightmare that parents dread most. They were called at work by their child-care provider and told that their 18-month-old son had died in a crib accident. Imagine their anguish when they later learned that other children had died in this model of crib, and that still others had died in cribs with similar design. Yet there was no easy way for any parent or child-care provider to know that.

In a recent three-year span, some 265 children under the age of 5 died in accidents related to nursery products, the government has reported. If this program could reduce that number even slightly, the cost would seem amply justified.

Moving the government into the 21st century should be applauded. In a future column, I will explain how the release of some kinds of data can even help consumers better understand themselves.

 

Richard H. Thaler is a professor of economics and behavioral science at the Booth School of Business at the University of Chicago.

 

 

 
Phil Ting's picture

Small Investment will go a Long Way

Submitted by Phil Ting on Tue, 03/15/2011 - 10:28pm.

Open Data takes the information government already tracks and gets it to the public in a user friendly format.  SF already has great information reagarding bus timelines, however due to the MUNI system issues, I continue to hear about how NextBus doesnt always have reliable information.  Our office help pioneer a master address database so the City would have one database of addresses which could be shared with Public Works and Planning.  This is the just the tip of the iceberg.  We are trying to develop software so the public can track customer requests and see where we are in working the problem.  This is the future for government.  Imagine if we could see when a pothole will get fixed, when the firetruck might arrive or environmental data.

Paid for by Phil Ting for Assembly 2012. FPPC ID# 1343137

  • Home
  • Site Map
  • FAQ
  • Words to Know
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Feedback

SIGN IN
TO RESET SF

  Connect


Search

中文
Español
Việt
Русский

My Profile
Join Reset SF
About Reset SF
Neighborhoods
SF FAQ
Meet the Team
Contact

About Phil Ting
Ting for Assembly
Contribute
Events

Connect:

Facebook Twitter  


      Discuss
The Issues:

Transportation

Education

Better Gov't

Environment

Tax Reform

Neighborhoods

Public Safety

          Jobs

Housing

Arts & Culture

SF Favorites


Learn More About Our Site:
 

Learn About Reset San Francisco

 


Watch Now:

Reset San Francisco Youtube

    
  Reset San Francisco Ask an Expert  Reset San Francisco Blog
  Reset San Francisco Youtube  Reset San Francisco Toolkit


SF News

  • Oakland Crews Working on 2-Alarm Fire This Morning
  • Powerball Ticket Sold In San Jose Worth $2.3 Million
  • Caltrain Service Affected By Small Fire Near Tracks In Sunnyvale
  • Crews Douse Pier Fire In Central Waterfront-Dogpatch District
  • Solano County Man Killed in Crash Drove Wrong Way For Nearly 9 Miles
  • San Francisco Bay Area Monday Morning News Roundup
  • East Palo Alto Teen Killed, Two Others Injured in Shooting
  • San Francisco Bay Area Friday Midday News Roundup
  • Fire Damages Forbes Island Restaurant At Pier 41
  • Firefighters Respond To Fire At Pier 41 This Morning
  • San Francisco Bay Area Friday Morning News Roundup
  • San Francisco Bay Area Thursday Morning News Roundup
  • San Francisco Bay Area Wednesday Morning News Roundup
  • San Francisco Bay Area Tuesday Morning News Roundup
  • Bay Area Firefighters To Help Fight Springs Fire
>> read more

Gov 2.0

  • Data Management Key To Federal Open Data Policy
  • GAO-13-417, Strategic Sourcing: Leading Commercial Practices Can Help Federal Agencies Increase Savings When Acquiring Services, April 15, 2013
  • Maryland launches statewide open data portal
  • 10 Ways Civic Hacking Can Benefit Your Community
  • Project aims to track big city carbon footprints
  • San Jose Police Department Launches CityConnect App
  • In rural W.Va., schools rethink their role
  • With Parks Investment, Grass Becomes Houston's Green Gold
  • Payphone Wi-Fi Piloted in Boston
  • NYC To Try Longer School Day In 20 Middle Schools
  • For Planners, Investment in Social Media Pays Dividends
  • 7 Ideas for the Future of Local Government
  • Using SNAP Receipt to Establish, Verify, and Renew Medicaid
  • US patent office embraces big data
  • Cities and data: By the numbers
>> read more

Stay Engaged

Sign up for the Reset
San Francisco Newsletter

Reset Right Now

Join Phil Ting for Assembly

Support the Middle Class Scholarship
     Legislation

Phil Ting: An API for Ethics in City Gov't

VIDEO: Your Thoughts on Muni

Time for Universal Internet Access

Is New York City Taking the Lead?

San Francisco Needs Open Government

Have a question about San Francisco? Learn more on our FAQ page!

Reset Ratings

Reset Revealed

Petition to Save GoSolarSF

Become a Reset San Francisco Intern

Vote Now

Poll

Do you think gun owners should be required to get liability insurance in CA?

Recent Posts

  • nike tn at footlocker,tn pas cher homme by Dravysherssek
  • air jordan retro 17 by Dravysherssek
  • iouiasw by viagra
  • Home Elevators Loan Calculator: Correctly By Means Of Discovering The Basic loan calculator by whistreningna1972
  • Have You Any Idea How You Can short term loans companies. Do You Realize A Way To short term loans companies by whistreningna1972
  • Can You Be Sure Methods To Additional Info: Are You Aware Of The Best Way To Additional Info by whistreningna1972
  • Are You Ideas On How To payday loan. Information And Facts payday loan by whistreningna1972
  • Are You Tips On How To payday loan with bad credit: Thought The Best Way To read more by whistreningna1972
  • Media Payday Loan: Reports Regarding Payday Loan by whistreningna1972
  • Correctly Due To Understanding The Concepts Of Basic loans against cars: Securely Through Process Of Finding Out The Basic loans against cars by whistreningna1972
  • Announcement Click For More- Are You Aware Of Ways To Bank Loans by whistreningna1972
  • Concept Simple Methods To payday loans, Properly Just By Trying To Learn Basic Principles payday loans direct lender by whistreningna1972
  • Concept The Best Way To bad credit loans no guarantor: Do You Know Methods To Bad Credit Loans by whistreningna1972
  • Don'T Know How To direct loans 1099, Did You Know Simple Methods To direct loans 1099 by whistreningna1972
  • Confidently From Understanding The Concepts Of Basic Fundamentals . Can You Be Sure Ideas On How To by whistreningna1972
  • Facts About Short Term Loans, Risk-Free Via Figuring Out How Regarding short term loans by whistreningna1972
  • Are You Aware Of Ways To 12 month loans. Information About 12 month loans rates by whistreningna1972
  • http://faster12monthloans.co.uk by whistreningna1972
  • Information Guarantor Loans. Are You Easy Methods To Why Not Try These Out by whistreningna1972
  • Details guarantor loans interest rates, Subject On guarantor loans by whistreningna1972
>> more

Custom Drupal Website by RealTidings, LLC